Today’s offering to the JG gun debate.
Re: Gordon E. Walter’s letter, Founders’ vision needs
modern update of Mar 3, 2018
Let’s take Walter’s idea about “updating” the Second
Amendment and apply it to the First Amendment.
The founders couldn’t have foreseen the Internet, TV,
radio and mobile devices that keep the population instantaneously updated on
current events and opinions.
Using Walter’s logic, the only methods for informing
the public that should retain today’s First Amendment protections are town
criers and publications printed using movable type, ink rollers and capable of printing
one page at a time on a printing press.
If that sounds silly, it’s only because it is silly. If
it’s silly for the First Amendment it is just as silly when applied to the
Second Amendment.
The constitution is not a cafeteria menu. The
population is not subject to emotional arguments from people who think that
they can pick through this clause, ignore that amendment, take a little bit of
this Article and a bit of that one – but always taking just the stuff they like
while throwing the rest in the trash.
What the founders could not foresee they left a means
whereby the constitution could be amended. With regard to the Second Amendment, that’s
something the Democrats will not touch with a 10 foot pole. For them, it’s
better to pretend that you’re interested in a solution than to ever offer one
that will expose your true aim.
With regard to school safety, that’s something that
could be fixed in a week without adding a single word to the more than 20,000
gun laws already in effect. For starters,
how about locking the doors, putting an armed guard outside and armed guard
inside and see how that works? Democrats
will not address “common sense” school safety because they’d rather complain
about guns and “common sense” school safety doesn’t infringe on anyone’s Second
Amendment rights.
Democrats always prefer having issues to having
solutions for issues.
Founders' vision needs
modern update
Altogether, the
Founding Fathers did a remarkable job of writing the Constitution, based on
history and the conditions they knew at the time.
There was no way they
could have foreseen automobiles, airplanes, telephones, electrical power grids,
nuclear energy, TV, computers and the Internet. However, when those
developments arrived, the Constitution allowed legislators to establish rules
for living safely with the new products.
For the Second
Amendment, we know the conditions facing the Founders. The “arms” they knew
were muzzle-loading rifles and single-shot pistols. An undisturbed expert
rifleman might make two or three shots per minute. It would take an assembled
militia to hold off a group of invaders.
Does anybody really
believe that Washington or Madison would have wanted everyone to have an AR-15?
Maybe, after the
latest tragedy, our legislators will have the common sense and courage to modernize
gun laws of the 18th century.
Gordon E. Walter
Fort Wayne
1 comment:
Other writings that are remarkable based on what was known at the time. Magna Carta, Bible, Gettysburg Address, I Have A Dream, and The Lex Dailies. Does Mr. Walter wish these all be updated, rewritten, expanded, or gutted?
Post a Comment